Bilqisti Rakat (2223180004) Well, I think it depends on the speaker or writer. the meaning to be conveyed by the writer or speaker, will be understand by the reader or listener on how the writer or speaker constructs words.
I agree with you. For the example, when someone hears the word "dog", some people may think dog is the adorable cute animal. But it could be that some other people consider it a rude curse. All depend on the individual and the context of the situation.
I agree with that statement which states that the meaning of some words is based on the reader thoughts. Because in my opinion departs from the thoughts of Ferdinand de Saussure who stated that there are seven divisions in the drive to get language, one of them is critical and means polarity. This is in line with the thought of Geoffrey Leech (1974) which states that there are at least 7 types of meanings in semantics, namely conceptual, connotative, social, affective, reflective, colocative, and thematic meanings. Therefore, the meaning of a word will differ depending on how the reader interprets the meaning of the word.
I agree with you. Because every person has the intent and purpose of the spoken word. However the spoken word must be pronounced clearly so that the person who hear it does not misunderstand.
Hello my name is Salsa Mutia and I disagree with your statement because i think the writer or the speaker also have a big role in delivering a meaning of a word. Because they are the one who made it. As you guys said in the presentation, types of meaning is divided into 7, and one of those is affective meaning. It said affective meaning refers to the speaker's feeling. So i think it is a bit wrong to say that the meaning of some word is based on the reader thought because the writer or the speaking also have a big role in deciding a meaning. Maybe if your statement is the meaning of some word is based on individual thought i will agree.
I agree with your statement, because in my opinion everyone has a different concept or thought based on what they read. the amount of knowledge possessed by the reader will also make it easier for readers to be able to know the meaning of words. because in a sentence, the meanings are connected to one another, it is important for us to be able to understand the concept and increase vocabulary to find out the true meaning. Not only is the correct meaning according to the dictionary, but also the meaning that is in accordance with what the author conveys based on the context in the sentence.
I agree with your group because even the writer has his/her imagination but the reader must have it too. The interpretation, the way to imagine something is different by each person. It depends on their background, environment, experience, and personality. So, i agree with that statement.
I agree with your statement. Because this is related to our ability to interpret the meaning of the word. And in my opinion, everyone has a different interpretations and thought when they read. Based on Geoffrey Leech which divides meaning into seven types namely conceptual, connotative, social, affective, reflected, collocative, and thematic meaning. Which I can conclude that meaning can be influenced by several factors. Some of the example such as our memory of the word, our emotions when we read the word, stress and intonation when we read the word, and etc. Not only that, in my opinion it also influenced by how the author or writer construct the words that want to convey.
I agree with your statement. Every word does have its own meaning and all the meaning returns to what the reader thinks. And each reader with other readers will have different thoughts or different points of view. Therefore, the meaning of the reading that is read will have a different meaning.
In my opinion, everyone have different perspective to understand the meaning of words based on their own knowledge. But the role of the writers also important to deliver the meaning of words or the main point on their writing.
I agree that the meaning of some words is based on the reader thought, because everyone has their own understanding of something and a different point of view of something. However, I think the way of the writer or speaker conveys something is also important, so what the speaker or writer wants to convey is conveyed well to the reader or listener. So, the meaning of some words is based on the reader's thought is true, but the writer or speaker must be able to convey something well, if they want the reader has the same thoughts with them. (Cahyani Octavia/4A) (2223180058)
I agree with your statement, because some words have double or ambiguous meaning. For example, if you find a word "snake" in your text or reading material; the word "snake" could be interpreted as an animal or a personality trait (evil). So, it depends on people who read it. But, don't forget that the writer or speaker also has to put the word with double or ambiguous meaning with a proper context in order to make the reader doesn't have any miss communication.
my name is nabilah nurul a (2223180064) and in my opinion everyone has their own way to deliver the meaning of words. Based on the writer, there are 7 types of meaning that often we all feel / think. I think the author has conveyed his ideas well so I am pleased with their statements and good job sist bro
I agree with this group statement, because basically everyone has different thoughts in interpreting a word or sentence, because there are several words that have multiple meanings, and it depends on everyone's knowledge in interpreting it, and as a writer must also be able to convey the contents writing correctly so that it's easy for readers to understand.
I agree with the statement because as we all know in the english dictionary that there are some words that have more than 1 meaning to it hence when we speak or say something we have to put the word in the right context. In one of the types of meaning, conceptual meaning, which is the literal meaning of the word, when we think of a word we immediately picture the image of the word in our mind. For example, cat, we immediately know that its an animal with fur and has whiskers. So the concept of the word which we recognise the meaning of the word are saved in our thoughts and memories.
I agree with your statement. Because, according to Geoffrey Leech (1974) 7 seven types of meaning, that is "affective meaning" states the speaker feeling. The meaning that arises due to the reaction of the listener or reader to the use of words or sentences. Because everyone has different interpretations and thoughts. Depending on the individual and the context of the situation.
In my opinion some people perceive different meanings and the same meaning, from the writer or from the speaker. Because everyone has their own way to deliver the meaning of words.
I agree with this statement, because every single person has their own thought.it proves,when i tried to identfy some words i thought the meaning was "A" but actually it was "B" /Idiom (2223180037)
I agree with your group steatment, because in the seven types of meaning in semantics according to Geoffrey Leech (1974), i draw conclusion if some word is not only based on denotative meaning, is not only for dictionary. for example word " crocodile" in denotative meaning, crocodile mean the predator animal, or carnivora animal life in the river with the quiet water. but sometimes people interpreting word crocodile as the man with many girlfriend.i think everyone have different meaning to interpreting the meaning. so i agree with your steatment.
I agree with the statement expressed by group one. Because every reader has a translation of their own thoughts about what they are reading. Therefore, to avoid the mistaken meaning of communication, writing needs to consider the clarity of words, and avoid ambiguous words or sentences.
Well i agree with this statement, because the thoughts of a person are different, if a sentence is read by a child and a adult it will be different, their thinking will be different, because everyone's imagination will not be the same.
Based on other sources that I read the definition of meaning In semantics and pragmatics, meaning is the message conveyed by words, sentences, and symbols in a context. Also called lexical meaning or semantic meaning. Just want to add it because the definition of meaning from the paper I think is less specific.
I agree with this statement,because every reader has a different ability to describe and understand the meaning behind the words being read depending on the individual and the situation.
I agree with your statement. In my opinion there are some words that has double meanings and the meaning itself would be translated into different meaning depend on the receiver knowledge. So, to avoid the misunderstanding between the speaker and the reciever, both of them must know what the context they are talking about.
i agree with the material. for example the writer said that Conceptual Meaning alludes to the word reference meaning which demonstrates the ideas. this type I often use in everyday life so I agree with the material.
I agree with the opinion that your group describes, because in some words there are words that cannot be interpreted if followed by denotativ, such as the word "stove" in Indonesian, stoves not only describe tools for cooking, but sometimes people interpret stoves as people who exaggerate the problem.
I agree with this group opinion, because everyone has their own thoughts of what they read. therefore, the author must convey the contents of the writing clearly. so, the reader does not misinterpret what is meant by the author.
I learned from the material that there are many kind of meanings and there are some words that is the same but different meaning it depends on the situation.
Bilqisti Rakat (2223180004)
BalasHapusWell, I think it depends on the speaker or writer. the meaning to be conveyed by the writer or speaker, will be understand by the reader or listener on how the writer or speaker constructs words.
I agree with you. For the example, when someone hears the word "dog", some people may think dog is the adorable cute animal. But it could be that some other people consider it a rude curse. All depend on the individual and the context of the situation.
BalasHapus2223180094
Rimah Erpiana 4A
yes i agree because everyone has different thoughts from each other depending on the situation of each person.
BalasHapusPutri aulia nurulaini
2223180055
4A
I agree with that statement which states that the meaning of some words is based on the reader thoughts. Because in my opinion departs from the thoughts of Ferdinand de Saussure who stated that there are seven divisions in the drive to get language, one of them is critical and means polarity. This is in line with the thought of Geoffrey Leech (1974) which states that there are at least 7 types of meanings in semantics, namely conceptual, connotative, social, affective, reflective, colocative, and thematic meanings. Therefore, the meaning of a word will differ depending on how the reader interprets the meaning of the word.
BalasHapusNisa Solihati
2223180028
4A
I agree with you. Because every person has the intent and purpose of the spoken word. However the spoken word must be pronounced clearly so that the person who hear it does not misunderstand.
BalasHapusDhiya Azzalia
2223180095
4A
Hello my name is Salsa Mutia and I disagree with your statement because i think the writer or the speaker also have a big role in delivering a meaning of a word. Because they are the one who made it. As you guys said in the presentation, types of meaning is divided into 7, and one of those is affective meaning. It said affective meaning refers to the speaker's feeling. So i think it is a bit wrong to say that the meaning of some word is based on the reader thought because the writer or the speaking also have a big role in deciding a meaning. Maybe if your statement is the meaning of some word is based on individual thought i will agree.
BalasHapusI agree with your statement, because in my opinion everyone has a different concept or thought based on what they read. the amount of knowledge possessed by the reader will also make it easier for readers to be able to know the meaning of words. because in a sentence, the meanings are connected to one another, it is important for us to be able to understand the concept and increase vocabulary to find out the true meaning. Not only is the correct meaning according to the dictionary, but also the meaning that is in accordance with what the author conveys based on the context in the sentence.
BalasHapusMia Agustina
2223180034
4A
I agree with your group because even the writer has his/her imagination but the reader must have it too. The interpretation, the way to imagine something is different by each person. It depends on their background, environment, experience, and personality. So, i agree with that statement.
BalasHapusYanda Nurul Islami
2223180133
I agree with your statement. Because this is related to our ability to interpret the meaning of the word. And in my opinion, everyone has a different interpretations and thought when they read. Based on Geoffrey Leech which divides meaning into seven types namely conceptual, connotative, social, affective, reflected, collocative, and thematic meaning. Which I can conclude that meaning can be influenced by several factors. Some of the example such as our memory of the word, our emotions when we read the word, stress and intonation when we read the word, and etc. Not only that, in my opinion it also influenced by how the author or writer construct the words that want to convey.
BalasHapusTsabita Amalia
2223180019
I agree with your statement. Every word does have its own meaning and all the meaning returns to what the reader thinks. And each reader with other readers will have different thoughts or different points of view. Therefore, the meaning of the reading that is read will have a different meaning.
BalasHapusBella Ayu Herawati
2223180097
In my opinion, everyone have different perspective to understand the meaning of words based on their own knowledge. But the role of the writers also important to deliver the meaning of words or the main point on their writing.
BalasHapusMayfa Ika Mawarni
2223180063
4A
I agree that the meaning of some words is based on the reader thought, because everyone has their own understanding of something and a different point of view of something. However, I think the way of the writer or speaker conveys something is also important, so what the speaker or writer wants to convey is conveyed well to the reader or listener. So, the meaning of some words is based on the reader's thought is true, but the writer or speaker must be able to convey something well, if they want the reader has the same thoughts with them.
BalasHapus(Cahyani Octavia/4A)
(2223180058)
I agree with your statement, because some words have double or ambiguous meaning. For example, if you find a word "snake" in your text or reading material; the word "snake" could be interpreted as an animal or a personality trait (evil). So, it depends on people who read it. But, don't forget that the writer or speaker also has to put the word with double or ambiguous meaning with a proper context in order to make the reader doesn't have any miss communication.
BalasHapusDwiky segara 2223180013
4A
my name is nabilah nurul a (2223180064) and in my opinion everyone has their own way to deliver the meaning of words. Based on the writer, there are 7 types of meaning that often we all feel / think. I think the author has conveyed his ideas well so I am pleased with their statements and good job sist bro
BalasHapusI agree with this group statement, because basically everyone has different thoughts in interpreting a word or sentence, because there are several words that have multiple meanings, and it depends on everyone's knowledge in interpreting it, and as a writer must also be able to convey the contents writing correctly so that it's easy for readers to understand.
BalasHapusAnisa Bela Deputri
2223180016
I agree with the statement because as we all know in the english dictionary that there are some words that have more than 1 meaning to it hence when we speak or say something we have to put the word in the right context. In one of the types of meaning, conceptual meaning, which is the literal meaning of the word, when we think of a word we immediately picture the image of the word in our mind. For example, cat, we immediately know that its an animal with fur and has whiskers. So the concept of the word which we recognise the meaning of the word are saved in our thoughts and memories.
BalasHapusGadis Ayu
2223180118
I agree with your statement. Because, according to Geoffrey Leech (1974) 7 seven types of meaning, that is "affective meaning" states the speaker feeling. The meaning that arises due to the reaction of the listener or reader to the use of words or sentences. Because everyone has different interpretations and thoughts. Depending on the individual and the context of the situation.
BalasHapusTata Regita Putri (2223180127)
4A
In my opinion some people perceive different meanings and the same meaning, from the writer or from the speaker. Because everyone has their own way to deliver the meaning of words.
BalasHapusAl-fajr Bagus Andrian (223180100)
4A
I agree with this statement, because every single person has their own thought.it proves,when i tried to identfy some words i thought the meaning was "A" but actually it was "B"
BalasHapus/Idiom
(2223180037)
Komentar ini telah dihapus oleh pengarang.
BalasHapusI agree with your group steatment, because in the seven types of meaning in semantics according to Geoffrey Leech (1974), i draw conclusion if some word is not only based on denotative meaning, is not only for dictionary. for example word " crocodile" in denotative meaning, crocodile mean the predator animal, or carnivora animal life in the river with the quiet water. but sometimes people interpreting word crocodile as the man with many girlfriend.i think everyone have different meaning to interpreting the meaning. so i agree with your steatment.
BalasHapusAsep Eka Parmana
(2223180076)
I agree with the statement expressed by group one. Because every reader has a translation of their own thoughts about what they are reading. Therefore, to avoid the mistaken meaning of communication, writing needs to consider the clarity of words, and avoid ambiguous words or sentences.
BalasHapusName: Kartika Ratna Sophia
NIM : 2223180067
Well i agree with this statement, because the thoughts of a person are different, if a sentence is read by a child and a adult it will be different, their thinking will be different, because everyone's imagination will not be the same.
BalasHapus(Syahla nurhaliza/4A)
(2223180046)
Based on other sources that I read the definition of meaning In semantics and pragmatics, meaning is the message conveyed by words, sentences, and symbols in a context. Also called lexical meaning or semantic meaning.
BalasHapusJust want to add it because the definition of meaning from the paper I think is less specific.
-Tia Septiawati(2223180112)
4A
I agree with this statement,because every reader has a different ability to describe and understand the meaning behind the words being read depending on the individual and the situation.
BalasHapusKusnawati
(2223180106)
4A
I agree with your statement. In my opinion there are some words that has double meanings and the meaning itself would be translated into different meaning depend on the receiver knowledge. So, to avoid the misunderstanding between the speaker and the reciever, both of them must know what the context they are talking about.
BalasHapusNurul Hidayah
2223180070
i agree with the material. for example the writer said that Conceptual Meaning alludes to the word reference meaning which demonstrates the ideas. this type I often use in everyday life so I agree with the material.
BalasHapusMoch Jati Lailatul Akbar
4A
2223170074
I agree with the opinion that your group describes, because in some words there are words that cannot be interpreted if followed by denotativ, such as the word "stove" in Indonesian, stoves not only describe tools for cooking, but sometimes people interpret stoves as people who exaggerate the problem.
BalasHapusName: Siti Robiatul Adawiyah
Nim : 2223180102
I agree with this group opinion, because everyone has their own thoughts of what they read. therefore, the author must convey the contents of the writing clearly. so, the reader does not misinterpret what is meant by the author.
BalasHapusName : Amelia YF
Class: 4A
My name is Abiyyu and I agree with that because this material relate in real life
BalasHapusI agree with the statement, because the reader must be have own interpretation of word but it must be relate to the context that written.
BalasHapusName : Athar Nibras
NIM : 2223180052
I learned from the material that there are many kind of meanings and there are some words that is the same but different meaning it depends on the situation.
BalasHapusName : Hanifah Ufairah
NIM: 2223180109