Reference is something haring physical existence. While, sense is the opposite of it. Then, if there is a word “ghost”, do you think it includes in reference or sense? Please answer and give the reason.
In my opinion the word "ghost" is included in the reference, because "ghost" tells about a form, whether it's a shadow or other form, meanwhile sense explains about something that is completely intangible.
I think "ghost" is reference. We know that ghost is a name of object/concept (soul of a dead person). Ghost currently do not exist but could exist. Rimah Erpiana 2223180094
In my opinion, the word "ghost" is included in the reference. Because the word "ghost" is an expression that has a relationship between the expression of language whose use refers to the situation of the shadow of the expression used. Then the word "ghost" also refers to real objects or objects that can be seen. In order to better understand it, another example is the word "goat" which refers to the type of animal. So in the word "ghost" the meaning of the reference is the person who has died. Maybe that's my opinion, hopefully useful.
i think the word ghost is a reference because it is an object and it could be an expression that have a relation between the meaning of ghost itself and the situation.
In my opinion the word " ghost " is included in the reference. Because reference deals with the relationship between language and the word that can be proved by the thing in the real world. As we know, ghost is an apparition of a dead person, sometimes represented as a pale, almost transparent image of that person that some people believe appears to people who are alive. And I think the word " ghost" includes in constant reference, because ghost has a real appearance and also can be defined in other word or expression such as demon, devil, phantom, and so on.
I think ghost is the reference because ghost it is a real object and ghost is a word that we can see and feel. Ghost words existed even before Skeat pointed the phenomenon out. Sometimes, ghost words appear in dictionaries on purpose, even though in that case they are called.
in my opinion, the word "ghost" is included in the references, because ghosts actually exist and we believe that ghosts are real and can sometimes be seen. and the concept of reference is tied to the speaker's goals (for example, to identify something) and the speaker's beliefs.
Sense of an expression is something abstract that in the mind of speaker or language user. and and reference of an expression is a thing in the world. So, I think "ghost" is included in reference because this thing exist in the world and we believe they are available.
In my oppinion "ghost" is included SENSE, because when someone said "ghost" my mind directly interprets and think of image that represents of ghost. Even i have not seen it in the real. And it called concept mental representation.
I think the word 'ghost' is general, and when someone say 'ghost' to me, in my mind 'what kind of ghost?, is it pocong, or kuntilanak, or something like that?'.so 'ghost' has unclear entity or form, So I think 'ghost' include Sense. Maybe when there is someone say 'pocong' or say 'I saw pocong' I decide that word 'pocong' is reference beacuse it refers to ghost pocong, and word 'pocong' has clear entity or form.
I think "Ghost" include in Sense. Because "Ghost" is abstract, we can not proved the word "Ghost" with the thing in the real world and we have to imagine the meaning of ghost based on our experience, because there is no specific object to represent "Ghost".
In my opinion, the word "ghost" is a reference. A ghost is considered to be the spirit of a dead person. Scientists say that there are no ghosts, but so many people believe that there are real. So basically, the existence of ghosts cannot be proven because they are spirits.
In my opinion, the word "ghost" include sense, because ghost it doesn't real object or abstract. In other words ghost is no specific object.While the reference shows the thing in the real object or concreate. for example: book, a book is a real object and we can know what the book looks like. So, in my opinion the word "Ghost" is SENSE.
If we see in linguistics study, maybe "ghost" include reference, because ghosts are the embodiment of the soul of someone who has died which is has a shape or physical. And many people maybe almost everyone in this world believe that ghost is real. But, honestly I don't believe it, I think someone who has died, their soul will be at another realm (cannot escape from this afterlife). So I think "ghost" can be include on sense.
in my opinion it is very difficult to classify ghosts as a reference or sense, in oxford the meaning of ghost is the spirit of a dead person that a living person believes they can see or hear,because some people believe and some people do not. so in my opinion the answer depends on each individual, because in reference, language is related to the world. and because I have never seen a ghost before, so in my opinion ghost is include a sense.
I think the word "ghost" is reference. Although it's something abstract that doesn't have a real object, people know what it is i.e the visible disembodied soul of a dead person or something bad or scared.It's kind of imaginery object such as Santa claus, unicorns, elves etc.
In my opinion it is okay wether to put the word 'ghost' in reference or sense, because ghost is abstract or imaginary object based on someone's believe. If someone believe or ever seen the object in physical shape then it includes in Reference. And if someone doesn't believe and never seen them, of course it is just in their mind to identify the object concept, so it is included in Sense. But generally, I think ghost is reference. Because even tho the existence of ghost is not concrete, people have an agreement about its concept such as the embodiment of the soul of dead person.
In my opinion the word "ghost" is a reference, because actually "ghost" is an object, if "ghost" is not an object, it is still reference.Because in reference not only explain or refer to the form / physical only, the reference can explain something abstract.CMIIW
permission to respond, in my opinion the word 'ghost' in the thread refers to something that is still generally. So it is part of the sence, why because when we say the word 'ghost' it means something that is invisible and spooky, or smooth and untouched. But it doesn't rule out it is also a reference when people believe that someone who says the word 'ghost' means ghost.
Komentar ini telah dihapus oleh pengarang.
BalasHapusKomentar ini telah dihapus oleh pengarang.
BalasHapusIn my opinion the word "ghost" is included in the reference, because "ghost" tells about a form, whether it's a shadow or other form, meanwhile sense explains about something that is completely intangible.
BalasHapusDhiya Azzalia
2223180095
I think "ghost" is reference. We know that ghost is a name of object/concept (soul of a dead person). Ghost currently do not exist but could exist.
BalasHapusRimah Erpiana
2223180094
In my opinion, the word "ghost" is included in the reference. Because the word "ghost" is an expression that has a relationship between the expression of language whose use refers to the situation of the shadow of the expression used. Then the word "ghost" also refers to real objects or objects that can be seen. In order to better understand it, another example is the word "goat" which refers to the type of animal. So in the word "ghost" the meaning of the reference is the person who has died. Maybe that's my opinion, hopefully useful.
BalasHapusNisa Solihati
2223180028
i think the word ghost is a reference because it is an object and it could be an expression that have a relation between the meaning of ghost itself and the situation.
BalasHapusHanifah Ufairah
2223180109
In my opinion the word " ghost " is included in the reference. Because reference deals with the relationship between language and the word that can be proved by the thing in the real world. As we know, ghost is an apparition of a dead person, sometimes represented as a pale, almost transparent image of that person that some people believe appears to people who are alive.
BalasHapusAnd I think the word " ghost" includes in constant reference, because ghost has a real appearance and also can be defined in other word or expression such as demon, devil, phantom, and so on.
Mia Agustina
2223180034
I think ghost is the reference because ghost it is a real object and ghost is a word that we can see and feel. Ghost words existed even before Skeat pointed the phenomenon out. Sometimes, ghost words appear in dictionaries on purpose, even though in that case they are called.
BalasHapusNurina Chaerani Hidayat
2223180124
in my opinion, the word "ghost" is included in the references, because ghosts actually exist and we believe that ghosts are real and can sometimes be seen. and the concept of reference is tied to the speaker's goals (for example, to identify something) and the speaker's beliefs.
BalasHapusAnisa Bela Deputri
2223180016
Sense of an expression is something abstract that in the mind of speaker or language user. and and reference of an expression is a thing in the world.
BalasHapusSo, I think "ghost" is included in reference because this thing exist in the world and we believe they are available.
Kurnia Melinda
2223180043
Komentar ini telah dihapus oleh pengarang.
BalasHapusIn my oppinion "ghost" is included SENSE, because when someone said "ghost" my mind directly interprets and think of image that represents of ghost. Even i have not seen it in the real. And it called concept mental representation.
BalasHapusI think the word 'ghost' is general, and when someone say 'ghost' to me, in my mind 'what kind of ghost?, is it pocong, or kuntilanak, or something like that?'.so 'ghost' has unclear entity or form, So I think 'ghost' include Sense.
BalasHapusMaybe when there is someone say 'pocong' or say 'I saw pocong' I decide that word 'pocong' is reference beacuse it refers to ghost pocong, and word 'pocong' has clear entity or form.
I think "Ghost" include in Sense. Because "Ghost" is abstract, we can not proved the word "Ghost" with the thing in the real world and we have to imagine the meaning of ghost based on our experience, because there is no specific object to represent "Ghost".
BalasHapusCahyani Octavia
2223180058/4A
In my opinion, the word "ghost" is a reference. A ghost is considered to be the spirit of a dead person. Scientists say that there are no ghosts, but so many people believe that there are real. So basically,
BalasHapusthe existence of ghosts cannot be proven because they are spirits.
Yuniarti Kartika
2223180082/4A
In my opinion, the word "ghost" include sense, because ghost it doesn't real object or abstract. In other words ghost is no specific object.While the reference shows the thing in the real object or concreate. for example: book, a book is a real object and we can know what the book looks like. So, in my opinion the word "Ghost" is SENSE.
BalasHapusTata Regita Putri
(2223180127) 4 A
Komentar ini telah dihapus oleh pengarang.
BalasHapusIf we see in linguistics study, maybe "ghost" include reference, because ghosts are the embodiment of the soul of someone who has died which is has a shape or physical. And many people maybe almost everyone in this world believe that ghost is real. But, honestly I don't believe it, I think someone who has died, their soul will be at another realm (cannot escape from this afterlife). So I think "ghost" can be include on sense.
BalasHapusAhmad Fadlillah
2223180031
in my opinion it is very difficult to classify ghosts as a reference or sense, in oxford the meaning of ghost is the spirit of a dead person that a living person believes they can see or hear,because some people believe and some people do not. so in my opinion the answer depends on each individual, because in reference, language is related to the world. and because I have never seen a ghost before, so in my opinion ghost is include a sense.
BalasHapusName: Asep Eka Parmana
2223180076
You never seen your "jodoh" so, is jodoh include on sense?
HapusWhat the answer of your questions do you think, Ahmad? tell me 🤣
HapusI think the answer is reference, agung.. But I'm not sure, that is why I ask to ashepp 🤣
HapusI think the word "ghost" is reference. Although it's something abstract that doesn't have a real object, people know what it is i.e the visible disembodied soul of a dead person or something bad or scared.It's kind of imaginery object such as Santa claus, unicorns, elves etc.
BalasHapusBilqisti Rakat
2223180004
In my opinion it is okay wether to put the word 'ghost' in reference or sense, because ghost is abstract or imaginary object based on someone's believe. If someone believe or ever seen the object in physical shape then it includes in Reference. And if someone doesn't believe and never seen them, of course it is just in their mind to identify the object concept, so it is included in Sense.
BalasHapusBut generally, I think ghost is reference. Because even tho the existence of ghost is not concrete, people have an agreement about its concept such as the embodiment of the soul of dead person.
Mayfa Ika Mawarni
222318003
4A
In my opinion the word "ghost" is a reference, because actually "ghost" is an object, if "ghost" is not an object, it is still reference.Because in reference not only explain or refer to the form / physical only, the reference can explain something abstract.CMIIW
BalasHapusTia Septiawati
2223180112
So how to distinguish sense and reference? If and because both of them refer to something abstract. Thanks
Hapuspermission to respond, in my opinion the word 'ghost' in the thread refers to something that is still generally. So it is part of the sence, why because when we say the word 'ghost' it means something that is invisible and spooky, or smooth and untouched. But it doesn't rule out it is also a reference when people believe that someone who says the word 'ghost' means ghost.
BalasHapusKartika Ratna Sophia
2223180067
In my opinion, word "ghost" ghost is a reference. Because it represent a life or a creature. It means that word "ghost" has a form.
BalasHapusMuhammad Syafiq Gumilang
Hapus2223180115